Perhaps the director erred the mutiny is a much more grave and serious affair when it is committed by loyal seamen than when committed by low-class riff-raff.Īnother difference concerns Tinkler in the book, he is punished by being placed in the topmast until he is almost frozen in the movie, this punishment is meted out to Byam. Therefore, the mutiny in the movie is not carried out by loyal British seamen who are respected members of the navy but, instead, by the scum of the bars and jails, men who have no interest in anything but themselves. In the novel, the sailors actively petition the captain of the ship for the honor of service aboard the Bounty. First, in the movie, the sailors are "impressed," or forced, into service aboard the Bounty and thus have no feeling of allegiance to Bligh. This movie is closely based on the Nordhoff and Hall novel however, one should be aware of the differences between the novel and the movie. Mutiny on the Bounty (1935), starring Clark Gable, Hollywood's all-time favorite matinee idol, and Charles Laughton. The books are more complex and somewhat more believable for most readers for others, the films are more believable in that the reasons for the mutiny are graphically presented: (1) the captain, maniacal in his pursuit of a short cut to the West Indies, would have carried his men and his ship to an almost certain death, and (2) the men wish to return to their women in Tahiti and to their idyllic existence there. After the mutiny, the men discover Pitcairn Island, where Christian is accidentally killed because of the indiscretion of the mutineers.Ī key difference between the movies and the books on which the mutiny is based lies in the motivations for the mutiny itself. The 1962 version focuses on the adventure of the trip to Tahiti - the trials and tribulations of getting there, and the arrival at these idyllic islands. The most recently released movie, The Bounty, follows the general plot, yet differs greatly in that the narration is told from Bligh's point of view. Of the major movies, the first one follows the Nordhoff and Hall novel the most closely, especially in the latter sections of the novel. ![]() All of the movies, however, have one thing in common: they give a much more important role to Fletcher Christian than do any of the books not surprisingly, each movie features a popular matinee idol of the time. ![]() ![]() Each movie follows its source book to some extent likewise, each movie digresses from its source book in some instances. Likewise, there have been three highly successful movies based on the incident: Mutiny on the Bounty (1935), starring Clark Gable and Charles Laughton Mutiny on the Bounty (1962), starring Marlon Brando and Trevor Howard and The Bounty (1984), starring Mel Gibson and Anthony Hopkins. Bounty, (2) Nordhoff and Hall's Mutiny on the Bounty, and (3) Robert Hough's The Bounty. Since the historical mutiny aboard the Bounty in 1789, there have been three highly successful books about the incident: (1) Captain William Bligh's The Mutiny on Board H.M.S. Often, these books are romantic or adventure stories, such as The Three Musketeers or Mutiny on the Bounty. Some books or novels lend themselves to movie adaptation.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |